Discover Eagle Lake Community

Eagle Lake is a thoughtfully planned community encompassing more than 300 acres on the northeast side of Orcas Island. The property includes a 17-acre freshwater lake, forest, wetlands, wildflower meadows, community gathering spaces, and access to protected shoreline along the Strait of Georgia.

Created with a strong commitment to environmental stewardship, Eagle Lake includes just 45 circular homesites surrounded by extensive common land. The saltwater shoreline and adjoining uplands were donated to the San Juan Preservation Trust, helping preserve the community’s rugged coastal setting for generations.

Owners enjoy shared amenities including the lake, dock, Lake Shelter, Meeting House, community garden and orchard, playing field, picnic areas, and miles of trails and shoreline access. Underground utilities, community water and septic systems, and available fiber internet provide modern infrastructure within a carefully preserved natural landscape.

Depending on location, homesites may offer views across the Strait of Georgia toward Mt. Baker, the Cascade Range, Vancouver, nearby islands, forests, meadows, and the surrounding San Juan Islands. Architectural guidelines encourage homes that complement the landscape while allowing for a range of individual styles, from simple cabins to more substantial island retreats. Appointments are required to tour Eagle Lake and the available homesites.

359 Georgia Strait Lane

Price: $295,000

MLS 2515918

Stunning water views of Georgia Strait, and Barnes and Clark Islands. Located in a private and serene setting, this property is ready for your dream home. Lot 32 has a level building site with one of the best views in the Eagle Lake Community. Enjoy the benefits of this nature-oriented location with protected marine views, group water and community drain field. The Eagle Lake community comprises 292 acres of nature trails, waterfront & trout-stocked lake. HOA dues support community caretaker & residence, picnic shelter & many more amenities. Located near Washington State Park accessible nature trails at the Pt. Lawrence Preserve.

Lot 27 Georgia Strait Lane

Price: $225,000

MLS 2523791

Where the Forest Meets the Salish Sea. A beautiful Eagle Lake view lot for buyers ready to build and ready to live closer to the landscape. From the level building area, the view unfolds in layers: forest canopy below, long water views beyond, and the Cascade Range in the distance. It is the kind of overlook that invites daily observation—eagles overhead, deer moving through the trees, birdsong, changing weather, and the quiet rhythm of the woods below. A completed geo tech report, existing outbuilding, and utilities; water, power, fiber optic, and community drainfield, right at the road, create a clearer path forward than many vacant parcels. Eagle Lake appeals to those who want privacy, nature, and a strong sense of community without feeling isolated. Ownership includes access to 290+ acres of protected common land, miles of trails, a 17-acre freshwater lake, private Eagle Lake access, maintained roads, sunny community garden/play field, and clubhouse with showers and laundry for visits while you build. Nearby public lands add even more room to explore, including Moran State Park, Point Lawrence Preserve trails to the shoreline, and exclusive Land Bank shoreline access for Eagle Lake residents. Temporary camping is permitted. With fiber optic infrastructure, architectural review, and no vacation rentals allowed, this is a compelling Eagle Lake opportunity for buyers seeking water views, wildlife, and a practical path to building. Agent must accompany Buyer for showings.

212 Eagle Lake Lane

Price: $175,000

MLS 2445109

Tranquil lakeside Lot 5 is privately set near Girls’ Island, offering beautiful views of Eagle Lake & Mt. Pickett. A private driveway leads to an enchanting, mossy building area centered in a 100′ building circle. Property includes Atticus Design 2-bdrm concept plans w/ 3-D renderings, renewed 3bdrm septic design, topographic survey, 2025 Critical Areas reports—saving significant planning time & streamlining a path to your lakeside dream home. A haven for birdwatchers & hikers w/ fishing year-round. Temporary camping allowed w/ laundry & showers at the clubhouse. Enjoy 290+ acres of trails, a pristine 17-acre lake, ocean access, clubhouse, garden, playfield & more. Full-time caretaker; seller financing possible.Appointment required to tour.

41 Raven Lane

Price: $170,000

MLS 2522075

Perched atop a peaceful knoll in Eagle Lake community, Lot 41 is a special Orcas Island retreat offering sweeping east-facing views across Rosario Strait toward Barnes, Clark, & Lummi Islands, with the North Cascades in the distance. Surrounded by towering firs, graceful alders, & the quiet sounds of nature, this property feels wonderfully serene. The existing view corridor is already captivating, with additional view enhancement potential through selective limbing & view easement opportunities. The 100-foot building circle has been marked, & extensive groundwork completed, including a 2022 site plan, geotech report, & wetland analysis—helping streamline your vision. Water, power, & fiber internet are available near the driveway entrance. Community septic drainfield access is available with a tank-only system required. A charming custom cedar storage shed is included. Ownership in Eagle Lake includes access to over 290 acres of protected common land & trails. Residents enjoy a pristine freshwater lake ideal for swimming, fishing, & paddleboarding, community beach & ocean access, clubhouse with shower & laundry facilities, community garden spaces, & abundant wildlife. Temporary camping is permitted, making it easy to enjoy the property right away while planning for the future. Whether envisioned as a seasonal escape or future dream home, this beautiful property offers a rare blend of tranquility, infrastructure, natural beauty. Seller financing avail. to qualified buyers.

36 Coastline Drive

Price: $145,000

MLS 2502113

Build your perfect retreat getaway with protected marine views. Lot 36 on Coastline Drive is perched above Georgia Strait with a cleared level 100′ diameter building circle. Eagle Lake is an end-of-the-road private community offering a resort-like setting on 290 acres with common recreational amenities including 3830 feet of salt water beach access, 292 acres with miles of walking trails, a clubhouse, and a large 17-acre fresh water lake perfect for swimming, paddling and fishing. Includes schematic drawings by Heliotrope. Possible to improve the view with selective limbing/topping. HOA dues are $1809 quarterly cover: road maintenance, garbage, water, septic drain-field maintenance, snow removal, taxes on common land, and full time caretaker. Camping allowed before building with showers and laundry available. Buyers must have an appointment with a broker to visit the property.